How to Write an Effective Response to Reviewers: 5 Tips

In the case your work has been reviewed and has received feedback from your peer experts, there needs to be a proper response to reviewers. A response to the reviewers does not necessarily mean that you need to disagree, argue, or prove the reviewers wrong. With a response, you are trying to be dynamic and convincing enough to let your reviewers know that you have indeed made the perfect changes to your work. A response, therefore, is about making a good impression on the reviewers.

12.05.2021

How to Write an Effective Response to Reviewers: 5 Tips

This article discusses how to write an effective response to reviewers. To give you an opportunity to practice proofreading, we have left a few spelling, punctuation, or grammatical errors in the text. See if you can spot them! If you spot the errors correctly, you will be entitled to a 10% discount.

Having your manuscript accepted by a publication is a great honor for any author. However, along with being accepted, the journal editor may also ask you to make certain changes in your work after having it reviewed by peers. While some of the reviews may be disappointing and discouraging, one must understand that even the harshest of the reviews will only help you make your manuscript better. After all, the common goal is to publish the best papers.

Therefore, in the case your work has been reviewed and has received feedback from your peer experts, there needs to be a proper response to reviewers. A response to the reviewers does not necessarily mean that you need to disagree, argue, or prove the reviewers wrong. With a response, you are trying to be dynamic and convincing enough to let your reviewers know that you have indeed made the perfect changes to your work. A response, therefore, is about making a good impression on the reviewers.

1. Overview is important

The format for a response should always include an overview. In the overview, list all the necessary changes and reviews. You may also include numbers, tables, and figures to explain your point better. Once you have stated the overview, you may proceed with individually addressing every review and conveying your response to each of them.

2. Remember to be respectful

It is important to understand that it is a professional platform; therefore, professionalism and respect should not be overlooked. Even if you may not agree with the reviewer or may think them incapable of understanding your views, you must not convey that to the reviewers. They may be discouraging, competitive, or even demeaning. However, you must treat them with careful words. Try to understand their remarks and come up with respectful ways of confronting them.

3. Accept your mistakes

This is another courteous habit to maintain while preparing a response to the reviewers. Even if you do not agree with the changes or believe that your piece of work has enough material to support the review, you should still convey it in a better manner. In the same manner, address the review of the reviewers by going revising it over. This way, you are paying respect to and understanding their concerns.

4. Edit and proofread your response again

While you are preparing your response, always edit and proofread it over and over again. You would need your response to be apt and accurate. Also, any mistakes here would only be humiliating and unwanted. If you do not have enough time to spare for editing and proofreading the response, you may also hire editing and proofreading services for better effect. You may find the following articles helpful:

· Why Do You Need Editing and Proofreading Services?

· How to Find a Reliable Proofreading Service: A Brief Guide

· 8 Benefits of Using Professional Proofreading and Editing Services

Effective Response to Reviewers

5. Consider the reviewer’s suggestions

Lastly, always consider the suggestions that the reviewer has made. You would not want to give your reviewers the impression that you were least bothered about their suggestions. As a polite and respectful move, review the suggestions that were made. If you find them compelling the matter of your work, give a polite and clear explanation of why the suggestion may not fit well with your work.

Writing a response to the reviewers can be overwhelming. However, if you consider these few tips, you will be able to get your materials straight and prepare an effective response.

Do you need an expert to review and edit your response to reviewers?

Have you completed your response? Do you want someone to review the entire article or your response only and make necessary changes if required? If yes, we bring the most trusted and efficient editing and proofreading services near you. At Best Edit & Proof, our experts will edit and proofread your response and article to make necessary changes.

Best Edit & Proof expert editors and proofreaders focus on offering manuscripts with proper tone, content, and style of academic writing and also provide an upscale editing and proofreading service for you. If you consider our pieces of advice, you will witness a notable increase in the chance for your research manuscript to be accepted by the publishers. We work together as an academic writing style guide by bestowing subject-area editing and proofreading around several categorized styles of writing. With the group of our expert editors, you will always find us all set to help you identify the tone and style that your manuscript needs to get a nod from the publishers.

English manuscript formatting service

You can also avail of our assistance if you are looking for editors who can format your manuscript, or just check on the particular styles for the formatting task as per the guidelines provided to you, e.g., APA, MLA, or Chicago/Turabian styles. Best Edit & Proof editors and proofreaders provide all sorts of academic writing help, including editing and proofreading services, using our user-friendly website, and a streamlined ordering process.

Get a free quote for editing and proofreading now!

Kindly visit our order page if you want our subject-area editors or language experts to work on your manuscript to improve its tone and style and give it a perfect academic tone and style through proper editing and proofreading. The process of submitting a paper is very easy and quick. Click here to find out how it works.

Our pricing is based on the type of service you avail of here, be it editing or proofreading. We charge on the basis of the word count of your manuscript that you submit for editing and proofreading and the turnaround time it takes to get it done. If you want to get an instant price quote for your project, copy and paste your document or enter your word count into our pricing calculator.

24/7 customer support | Live support

If you need support for editing and proofreading services, contact us. You can also e-mail us or use the 24/7 live chat module to get direct support. We have a 24/7 active live chat mode to offer you direct support along with qualified editors to refine and furbish your manuscript. Alternatively, you can text us through our WhatsApp business line.

Effective Response to Reviewers

Stay tuned for updated information about editing and proofreading services!

Follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, and Medium.

For more posts, click here.

Do you like this article? Make sure to share and subscribe!

They Also Read

Academic Writing
7 Tips to Write an Effective Research Paper
12.05.2021

Preparing a research paper is the most painstaking and challenging task for many individuals. However, with rigorous practice, it would be much hassle-free for you to sum up entirely. Are you thinking of the best ways to write an impactful research paper? We are here to help you! We present an easy-to-follow rubric that will help you draft an impeccable research paper.

Continue Reading
Grammar Rules Academic Writing
Most Important Language Rules to Improve Your Academic Writing
12.05.2021

Academic writing is one of the most systematic writing formats to exist. This type of writing requires you to have precise knowledge about writing formats, style guides and still has additional rules to follow, depending on your type of work. Though it is not something otherworldly and is very much attainable through practice, it can still be a chaotic mess for beginners. A good way to improve yourself is to familiarize yourself with the language rules. In this article, we will take a look at the most important language rules that you must know of and exercise eventually.

Continue Reading
Editing & Proofreading Academic Writing Editing
5 Essential Information Your Editor Needs
12.05.2021

After writing your manuscript, you may likely decide on an editor to perform the final checks on your document. Mostly, authors make the mistake of sending their manuscripts to their editors, without providing adequate information about specifications on the service they seek. With such limited information, your editor may produce an unsatisfactory job with limited information at his/her disposal. Thus, to ensure that your editors provide the best possible service, which will prevent journals from rejecting your manuscripts on the grounds of noncompliance to journal requirements, the following information should be provided beforehand.

Continue Reading
Academic Writing
5 Common Academic Writing Problems | How to Deal with Them
12.05.2021

Writing for academic purposes demands extreme finesse. It is not just the language that should be exemplary. Even the diction, the tone, and the context of the text should be on point. However, the path to achieving this finesse is a troublesome one. Many scholars, while treading this path, come across a myriad of academic writing problems that they find it too cumbersome to overcome. These problems can concern their language skills, research capabilities, or lack of awareness regarding their field of study. The purpose of this article is to address some of these recurring academic writing problems and suggest ways to deal with them.

Continue Reading
Academic Writing
Business Writing vs Academic Writing: Four Primary Differences
12.05.2021

Some might say that the only difference between academic and business writing is the fact that the former is practiced by scholars while the latter by professionals. However, when perused closely, one can discern some stark as well as nuanced demarcation between the two. For individuals, such as college graduates, who need to occasionally shift between academic writing and business writing, knowing these differences can help them format their respective documents appropriately.

Continue Reading